MUSEUMMagazine
English

Van Meegeren: the Vermeer that was not a Vermeer

On 12 June 1945 an Amsterdam painter claimed that the Vermeer in Göring’s collection was his own work. How he made new look old, how his Supper at Emmaus convinced a museum, and how a blue pigment gave him away after all.

An easel and painting materials in an empty studio.
Image credits

On 12 June 1945 an Amsterdam painter says something nobody wants to believe. The painting he sold to Hermann Göring, Christ with the Adulteress, is not a Vermeer. He made it himself. Han van Meegeren has just been arrested and is charged with collaboration. Captain Harry Anderson had found the canvas in Göring’s collection in May 1945.

Henricus Antonius van Meegeren was born in Deventer in 1889. He studied architecture at the Delft Institute of Technology and then turned to painting. Recognition from the art establishment never came. He wrote for the magazine De Kemphaan and lived in Roquebrune in France, where he made his Emmaus forgery.

A pigment jar, palette knife and cloth on a workbench.
AI-generated image OpenAI ImageGen · Eigen redactiebeeld

His biggest problem was time. Oil paint needs about fifty years to harden, and a seventeenth-century painting would have to be hard right through. He spent about four years looking for a solution. He mixed his pigments with a synthetic resin instead of oil and then baked the canvas. As a base he took a real seventeenth-century painting, most of whose image he scraped away with pumice and water. The original canvas stayed, with its network of fine cracks, the craquelure. A religious subject and an early style also disguised his technical weaknesses.

The public saw the result in 1937. Abraham Bredius, a leading authority on Vermeer, confirmed that Christ and the Disciples at Emmaus was a Vermeer. The painting was bought with donations from, among others, the Stichting Rembrandt, shipowner W. van der Vorm, Bredius himself and private donors, and went to Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen in Rotterdam. The museum calls it the most famous falsification in Dutch art history: it was sold as a Vermeer and only unmasked as a clever fake after the Second World War, following Van Meegeren’s confession. It measures 130.5 by 118 centimetres. In the upper left corner a barely visible signature reads ‘IVmeer’.

Bredius wrote in his article about the discovery that the canvas was ‘every inch a Vermeer’, ‘the masterpiece of Johannes Vermeer of Delft’. Few colleagues doubted him; he went by the nickname ‘the Pope’. The painting cost 520,000 to 550,000 guilders and became the museum’s top attraction. Van Meegeren did not stop there. He also made The Washing of the Feet, which the Dutch state bought for 1,250,000 to 1,300,000 guilders. His own explanation was disappointment: artists and critics gave him no recognition. After he was exposed, the expert De Vries cut the number of Vermeers from 43 to 35 in 1948.

The paint holds a clue. The Supper at Emmaus contains natural ultramarine, the expensive blue Vermeer did use. The pigment is contaminated with cobalt blue. That was discovered in 1803-1804 and has been used as a pigment since 1806. A painter from the seventeenth century could not have had it in his paint.

So what did he do with the profit? For Christ with the Adulteress Hermann Göring paid 1,650,000 guilders. In exchange he gave Van Meegeren Dutch paintings that the Nazis had looted. So the forger earned his money from the occupier as well.

To prove his story, Van Meegeren painted Jesus Among the Doctors in 1945, under police guard. The trial began on 29 October 1947 in Amsterdam. The charge of collaboration was changed to forgery, and the judge gave him one year in prison. Shortly afterwards he died, aged 58, of a heart attack. He is estimated to have earned more than seven million guilders from his forgeries.

The museum in Rotterdam keeps working with the forgery. The Supper at Emmaus was shown in The Collection as a Time Machine (2017), in Fake? (2016), in Forgeries? Forgeries! (2022) and in a presentation for the Vermeer year (2023). In the museum’s registration system the provenance lists only the art dealer D.A. Hoogendijk. The blue Van Meegeren used was traditionally made from ground lapis lazuli. Natural and artificial ultramarine look almost alike, but laboratory tests show the difference, so a researcher can check which pigment is in a painting.

In 1949 P.B. Coremans’s book Van Meegeren’s Faked Vermeers and de Hooghs appeared. The Emmaus painting no longer hangs as a Vermeer in a gallery, but the canvas remains as the painting that made a museum, an expert and a country believe what they wanted to see.

Practical

Artist: Han van Meegeren (Deventer 1889 - Amsterdam 1947)

Painting: The Supper at Emmaus, 1937, oil on canvas, 130.5 x 118 cm

Detail: natural ultramarine contaminated with cobalt blue

Van Meegeren’s trial: began 29 October 1947, Amsterdam

Sources and image credits →

Sections

Museum mapDiscover museumsHomeMuseum storiesArt in focusWorld & objectBehind the scenesEvents